The beauty community on YouTube has had it’s fair share of drama, with people having a platform to voice their opinions its no surprise as there are always a group of people who disagree with one another. Although there are so many positive aspects of having such a large following on YouTube, there of course, are negatives. Recently, the 19 year old “beauty guru” came under fire after a friend, Tati Westbrook, made a video addressing some of his toxic behaviour.
James Charles first earned his fame from being a beauty guru, being the first male spokesmodel for CoverGirl Cosmetics and being very openly gay, however he is also known for the controversies he has been involved in.
Tati’s lengthy video (43 minutes) explained that he had acted in a disgusting manner towards a waiter at her birthday meal – the 37-year-old said that she explained that the waiter was in fact straight, James simply replied with “It doesn’t matter, I’m a celebrity” this sparked fury from his fans. Originally people were unsure on if this was true, but the waiter later released his own video explaining – including recordings of a call with the YouTuber and even screenshots from direct messages, the pair shared.
The waiter, Sam, admitted he wasn’t certain of his sexuality due to the fact he hadn’t experimented. After his sister got him to message James – a casual conversation with typical small talk. At some point James invited him to a hotel room, not thinking much of it Sam happily went there, where they began talking for a bit before making out.
After this, Sam said he left and after a few days he send James a text politely explaining that he was quite certain he wasn’t gay. James didn’t seem too keen on Sam’s response, even after Sam told him he wished to split on good terms.
In a text conversation James said to him “You’re not straight, no matter how many times you tell yourself” this is not the first case of James trying to pressure straight men into thinking they are either gay or bisexual.
This also, is not the only allegations against James at the moment as even bigger celebrities such as Zara Larsson, after the whole situation started trending on Twitter, the 21-year-old revealed that James had tried this with her boyfriend multiple times despite knowing he wasn’t gay.
There was another incident at the beginning of the year involving the model Gage Gomez after a photo surfaced of the pair together at Coachella back in April. Rumours had it that they were dating – despite any proper evidence. However, James later replied to a fan who asked about them saying “Nope unfortunately I am still very single. This boy played me for months on end and is a disgusting con artist. I’m thankful I had my friends with me to protect me” the tweet has later been deleted but he also had tweeted “This is no one’s fault but my own because my dumb a** continues to go for the same type of insecure cute boys and it gets me hurt every. single. time. I f*****g hate myself” this sent fans into a frenzy as they tried to defend him – instantly accusing the model of using James for his fame and popularity.
The model in the end created a YouTube channel solely for the fact of sharing his side of the story stating that he was creating the video to bring light to the “lies, false allegations and more importantly – the slander” as it was not only affecting him, but his friends and family also.
He denied the allegations that he was using James for his money and fame, before posting a longer video explaining in detail what happened between them.
According to Gage, he and James began talking during January 2019. He had made it very clear that he was straight, he also said that James kept insisting that they meet and got angry when the model was unavailable due to his busy schedule before he later accepted meeting up at Coachella.
James has even recently stated that he does not consider himself to be “completely gay” because of his attractions to girls and trans guys as well as the fact he pursues straight men. This statement caused a lot of controversy especially now since he claimed the waiter, Sam, was “not straight no matter how many times he told himself” leading to a lot of backlash.
This scenario is a perfect example of some of the negative aspects of social media. People such as James Charles use their large following to their advantage – he used his platform after Gage declined any romantic advances because he knew the majority of his fans would easily go after Gage and throw abuse his way.
However after he deleted his tweets, he apologised to Gage over text where he said he tweeted them out of anger because his fans had caught on which he didn’t want happening…despite posting the image of the two and tweeting about his rejection.
Although Gage contacted him to apologise and to set things straight, James was nothing but hostile the entire time. During the end of the conversation Gage gives up with arguing and simply asks James to clear his name however, he takes this as an opportunity to argue.
He claims Gage used him for his fame and played with his emotions as he had got him into Coachella and because Gage had not “informed him” that he was not gay in the first place, he was in the wrong as he lead James on, etc.
James then refuses to clear his name as it would “give him more attention and more followers” to which Gage said he completely understood that James has dealt – and continues, to deal with hate and negativity on daily basis but in this case James is choosing to make his life hell, rather than just letting the two of them sort it out between them rather than his angered fans fighting for him.
Gage even said that he did like James – as a friend and did not feel any attraction to men and he did not mean any malice from the whole situation but completely understood what James was feeling and knew why he was upset. Gage once again apologised and asked if they could just drop everything and move on, both going their separate ways as it would be easier on both of them.
However, this all turned out to be allegations as James Charles released a video with the title “No more lies” where he proved his innocence by showing text messages between him and Jeffree Star – another big name in the beauty community, who had joined in the accusations calling James a “predator” and saying that he knew there was “something wrong with him”.
He was quickly shut down after fans pulled up tweets that Jeffree had posted back in 2010 where he too, boasted about the fact he “loved” straight guys, some fans even argued about his song “Straight Boys” as he used to be known for his music.
James showed the messages shared between the pair proving that he was in fact not in the wrong.